Bel-Air dives deep into the emotional complexities of trauma, anxiety, and identity, offering a truthful portrayal of Black experiences with mental health.
Most often in the bright and colourful world of Hollywood, the portrayal of mental health among Black people has been written with stereotypes and a lack of nuance, either sidelining their experiences or simplifying them in ways that strip them of their complexity.
The taboo nature of discussing mental health within some Black communities reflects the underrepresentation of Black characters dealing with various mental health issues. This signals a need for a shift away from keeping the mental health experiences of Black people on the back burner.
Often in media, Black men are expected to embody hyper-masculinity or play criminals. Even heroic portrayals tend to position them as protectors of white characters, depicting them as exceptionally strong, stoic individuals who endure hardship without emotional fallout. Black women face similar reductive portrayals, often subjected to violence and receive the least sympathetic treatment, regardless of whether they’re heroes or villains.
Several films have reinforced these stereotypes by portraying Black men in hyper-masculinized roles. An example is the 2001 film, Training Day, with Denzel Washington playing Alonzo Harris, a corrupt LAPD officer who embodies a hyper-masculinized, aggressive Black man who uses violence, manipulation, and intimidation to maintain power.
These portrayals dehumanize and fail to address the genuine experiences of various mental health issues within Black communities. The lack of nuanced storytelling and inclusion perpetuates and furthers the damaging stereotype that Black people don’t experience mental health issues to the same extent as others, or that they are somehow more resilient or immune.
Bel-Air, the reboot of Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, boldly challenges these portrayals. Now in its third season, the show leans into the drama of Will Smith’s story and deeply explores the psychological impacts of trauma, class tension, and identity—particularly from a Black perspective.
The show distinguishes itself from its predecessor with its in-depth exploration of the emotional and mental struggles of each character, portraying their internal conflicts in a raw and honest way. Emotional complexities are dealt with care and allow for a more realistic depiction of how a Black teenager might grapple with both external and internal battles.
For instance, Will’s move to Bel-Air is not just a physical relocation but an emotional and mental one. While the original series treated his arrival with humour and light-hearted moments, Bel-Air delves into the trauma behind his move, revealing the anxiety, fear, and emotional baggage he carries from Smith’s life in West Philadelphia.
The reboot also takes a more mature approach to Carlton Banks’s character. In the original show, Carlton’s quirks were often played for laughs, but Bel-Air presents him as a more complex individual, grappling with mental health issues like anxiety and substance use as coping mechanisms. This allows viewers to see Carlton not as a caricature, but as a layered, vulnerable individual.
The show also dismantles the “strong Black person” stereotype by allowing its characters to be vulnerable to express fear, anxiety, and trauma in a way that isn’t immediately dismissed or solved. This expands the spectrum of Black experiences on screen and opens space for conversations around mental health. It challenges the notion that Black men and women must always be tough to survive, offering instead a portrayal of Black resilience that includes emotional openness and vulnerability.
By creating space for its characters to feel and heal, Bel-Air sets a new standard in Hollywood for how Black stories, especially those involving mental health, should be told with nuance, empathy, and truth.
Tags
Bel-Air, Hollywood, Mental health, Show
All final editorial decisions are made by the Editor(s)-in-Chief and/or the Managing Editor. Authors should not be contacted, targeted, or harassed under any circumstances. If you have any grievances with this article, please direct your comments to journal_editors@ams.queensu.ca.